Banned Reason: bash thread:
Floppy J. Flop
___u mad cuz your queen is not
seeing success? u mad cuz she can
barely scan gold and pays her bills
by singing about chicken wraps?
where is her sold out tour? she
ain't getting paid 18 mil to sit
and comment last I checked? Never
come for Godriah or King Bey while
stanning for a crack whore. That is
Ban Expiry Time: Permanently Banned
I will say this though. American Idol is not a show that accelerates those with the whole package or whatever. Shows like X Factor do that. American Idol is straight vocals and that's about it. Though, for example, I don't think Brit or Mary J. would make it to Hollywood on AI, they are unique in their own right and they bring their own special things to the music industry and if they tried out for AI, you wouldn't know the potential the REALLY had. Being a star isn't just about the voice. I feel there's a lot more to it. That's why I don't really like AI.
That's just my opinion though
Mary J Blige - YES
Ciara - NO
Rihanna - NO
Keyshia Cole - NO
Miley Cyrus - NO
Alicia Keys - YES
Britney Spears - NO
Taylor Swift - NO
P!Nk - YES
Beyonce - YES
Mariah Carey - YES
Ok Simon lol.
Ciara, Rihanna, Miley, Taylor, and Britney would all be cut instantly
Mary J Blige - Yes
Ciara - Yes
Rihanna - If She auditioned the way She saings now, yes if She did the way She did during her first two albums it's still a yes but She probably wouldn't have made it past the top 24)
Keyshia Cole - Yes
Miley Cyrus - Not at all
Alicia Keys - Yes. The piano would have added a certain appeal, She wasn't that bad when She first started out.
Britney Spears - I'm sorry & I love her but, no
Taylor Swift - HELL no !!
P!Nk - Yes DEFINITELY
Beyonce - of course !!
Mariah Carey - Yes. In her prime She would have BEEN the competition !!
Why nobody like Taylor
She can't sing at all.
I am CONVINCED She's tone deaf I don't care what anyone says
honestly my Ms.Jackson prolly wouldn't make it. But shes still the queen
I never thought of it that way. But you're right. Nicki must think like you
I agree with Nicki. Being successfu in the music industry doesn't just fall on "do you have the voice?"
It's about your presence/confidence, how you approach music, your niche.... everything. You can sound like a goat but with the right team and style and music, you can be a huge success.
And even if you do have the voice.... you could just have that and nothing else and be a flop flop flop lol
Ate you like Paula or something
What about Katy
Katy can sing She just needs a vocal coach, Her breathing is terrible & She has little to no control, plus She can't do a single run & She has NO vibrato, her voice is loud but very thin.
She could definitely use some work but the potential is there. Taylor rarely ever sings in key on CD, let alone live
only ones making it
Mary J Blige - yes
Ciara - no
Rihanna - no
Keyshia Cole - yes
Miley Cyrus - yes
Alicia Keys - yes
Britney Spears - no
Taylor Swift - no
P!Nk - yes
Beyonce - yes
Mariah Carey - yes
O_O Can you do one for so you think you can dance lmao
Only two people would make it off that list. LMAO